People’s Pulse ? People’s Confusion ?
DNA ( 12 July ) carries following report about launch of mobile app “ People’s Pulse “
PM Modi uses app to pick poll nominees, making netas worry
Despite 2 / 3 attempts , I could not download it
Then I filled in the survey online and got a feeling that it is quite wide ranging , and without any focus !
Why did I feel this way ?
To get a feel , take a look at the following format of the “ People’s Pulse “ :
SECTION A [ mandatory ]
Select your State / Constituency ( from drop-lists )
SECTION B [ mandatory ]
What do you think of the progress achieved by the Central Government in the following sectors ? ( 5 point scale of : Very Poor / Poor / Good / Very Good / Excellent ) . Each of the 12 sectors to be rated separately , one after another
Affordable Healthcare / Employment Opportunities / Rural Electrification / Farmer Prosperity / Fight against Corruption / Swachh Bharat / Road Construction / Connecting cities and towns by Airways / Up-liftment of Poor and Marginalized / National Security / Tackling Internal Security Threat / Economy
SECTION C [ mandatory ]
Do you think that the speed and the scale of govt work has improved ? YES …..NO
Are you feeling more optimistic than before about the future of India ? YES….. NO
SECTION D [ mandatory ]
How do you rate the performance of the Central Government ? ( 5 point scale as above )
SECTION E [ mandatory ]
How do you rate the performance of your State Government ? ( 5 point scale as above )
SECTION F [ mandatory ]
Which of the following issues is a prime consideration when you are voting ? ( multiple choices / choose any number of the following by ticking ✔ )
Price Rise / Law and Order Situation / Education / Employment / Cleanliness / Corruption / Farmer welfare
SECTION G [ optional ]
Name the three most popular BJP leaders in your constituency ( one after another to be rated independently )
Rate each of these leaders on 5 point scale as shown above :
Honesty and Integrity / Approachability and Humility / Popularity among Youth & Masses
SECTION H [ optional ]
Name the three most popular BJP leaders in your State
Rate on following ( same as above 5 point scale ) :
Honesty & Integrity / Approachability & Humility / Popularity among Youth and Masses
SECTION I [ optional ]
Please answer the following questions about your MLA
* Name of your MLA
* Are you aware about his / her initiatives ? YES ….. NO
* Is he / she , accessible ? YES ….. NO
* Are you satisfied with his / her work ? YES …… NO
* Does he / she solve people’s problems ? YES ….. NO
SECTION J [ optional ]
Please answer the following questions about your MP
* Name of your MP
* Are you aware about his / her initiatives ? YES ….. NO
* Is he / she accessible ? YES ….. NO
* Are you satisfied with his / her work ? YES ….. NO
* Does he / she solve people’s problems ? YES ….. NO
SECTION K [ mandatory ]
How happy are you with the condition of the following infrastructure in your constituency ? ( Rating of each item separately , on 5 point scale )
Roads / Power / Drinking Water / Healthcare / Education / Ration-related Issues / Job Opportunities / Law and Order / Cleanliness
SECTION L [ mandatory ]
* According to you, which are the three most popular Government Schemes ?
( Type free text in box )
* Do you have suggestions for PM Modi ? (Type free text in box )
* Do you listen to Mann ki Baat ? YES………….. NO
* Will you be interested in volunteering for BJP in 2019 Election ? YES…….NO
SUBMIT
The questions that passed my mind were :
* Is this a survey for evaluating the performance of the ,
# Central Government or of the State Government ?
# Govt Schemes or the performance of the local MLA / MP ?
* Is it to evaluate the present performance or assess the future potential of BJP
leaders ?
* Is this a GOVERNMENT survey or a BJP survey ?
* With as many as 13 SECTIONS ( distinct pages ) and a 5 point scale rating ( in most
questions ) , is this not too clumsy for a Mobile App ?
My Suggestions :
# If this purports to be a “ Central Government “ survey , there should be no mention /
reference to BJP .
Party can launch its own , separate Mobile App for evaluating the performance of its
own MPs and MLAs and for assessing the popularity / potential of its future candidates
for 2019 elections
I strongly recommend that Shri Amit Shah consider my following suggestion :
If he does ,
* He will get far better / precise feel of the “ People’s Pulse “
* He will know whom to re-nominate / drop from 2019 candidature
* Voters will have an assurance that their combined opinion will make a difference
* There will be a marked improvement , not only in the attendance of the MPs and
MLAs , but also in their behaviour within Lok Sabha / State Assembly
Amitbhai would do well to launch ROMP ( may be a modified version ) before Rahul
Gandhi comes out with something similar !
He may even want to learn about “ People’s Perception “ of the achievements of the
BJP government ( against is own 2014 Election Manifesto ), by implementing :
# There should be separate Apps for evaluating the performances of the,
* Central Government
* State Government
# Given the 5 point scale , most respondents will tend to select the “ median “ point ,
viz : GOOD . In study after study , this “ tendency to centralize “ has been observed
when deciding is difficult / time-consuming . People like to select an option which is “
Safe “ – nothing to go wrong ! Well-designed surveys have only “ YES .. NO “ or
“ TRUE…..FALSE “ type of selections
* In a Mobile App , no one has time ( or patience ) to write ( free text ) in boxes
Avoid these
* List of “ Sectors “ or “ Issues “ or “ Infrastructure “ is quite long
Either make it short ( 4 / 5 ) or do not make it mandatory to rate ALL
* If BJP leaders are really interested in election related REFORMS , they may want to
look up :
It is still not too late to treat the above blog as “ People’s Manifesto “ for
2019 general elections
It is high time 900 million voters stop reading Election Manifestos of the political
parties and come up with their very own , then tell the political parties :
“ We will vote for only that political party which commits itself to implementing our
Manifesto “
13 July 2018